The Citizens United decision overturns more than a century of campaign finance legislation and jurisprudence—at least with regard to corporations—and lays the foundation for the complete deregulation of campaign spending. The Court’s majority held that the First Amendment rights of corporations were violated by some modest and heretofore uncontroversial restrictions on election spending. The Court’s reasoning was premised on a view of corporate “personhood” that would have been unintelligible to the framers of the Constitution—and, as Justice John Paul Stevens demonstrated in his magisterial dissent, the majority’s opinion was fundamentally inconsistent with a long series of precedents. The decision is an aggressive assault on anemic and insubstantial restrictions that have failed to prevent the corporate dominance of our political system; consequently, although it is likely to encourage some highly political corporations to spend even more on electioneering, Citizens United mainly serves to clarify the brute fact that our political system is little more than a plutocracy. More disturbing than the curious judicial metaphysics of corporate personhood is the consistent equation of spending with speech. Indeed, throughout Justice Anthony Kennedy’s majority decision, the term “speak” was used in place of the words “contribute,” “spend,” and “buy.” This substitution is telling, and despite Kennedy’s vigorous assertions, most campaign spending is less a matter of intelligible speech than a pure show of force.
As for James Madison, without whom the Bill of Rights would never have been brought before Congress, much less ratified, we can be reasonably certain that he would never have extended First Amendment protection to the expenditures of corporations. In fact, during the First Congress, on February 8, 1791, in the midst of debate over Alexander Hamilton’s proposal to charter a Bank of the United States, Madison delivered a speech on the floor of the House denouncing the corrupting effects of “incorporated societies”: They are “powerful machines,” he argued, which often pursue principles that are very different from those of the people. No one who is familiar with Madison’s horror of all forms of political corruption could believe that he would have blithely extended the rights of citizenship to soulless creatures of pure commerce. Even so, the point is not whether one or another eighteenth-century politician would approve of a current law or court decision; what is at issue is the integrity of our political system. Citizens United confirms that we do indeed live in a “capitalist democracy,” as current usage has it, one in which a tiny minority quite literally votes with its pocketbook and in which laws and even lawmakers can be bought and sold like any other commodity.
Tuesday, October 12, 2010
A Plutocracy For Sure
Another statement by the previous post's Roger Hodge explains the serious damage done by the Citizen's United Supreme Court ruling to our political democracy:
Democrats Acting Like Republicans
Roger Hodge, former editor of Harper's magazine, summarizes the Left's problem with Obama, in response to a question about Robert Gibb's criticism of the Democratic 'professional Left':
I’m not sure Gibbs has a coherent idea of what he means by the “left,” but if opposition to permanent war, extrajudicial assassination of American citizens, boundless state secrecy, and unlimited corporate bailouts constitutes “leftism,” then so be it. True to their Clintonian principles, President Obama and his advisors have spurned the Democratic Party’s liberal base and have sought to govern by appropriating the policies of the Republican right. Just as Bill Clinton enacted NAFTA and destroyed welfare, Barack Obama has pushed through a health-care program that was inspired by the Heritage Foundation and largely written by the insurance lobby—and he shows every sign of being willing to vandalize Social Security in the name of deficit reduction even though the program has nothing to do with the federal budget deficit. Obama has embraced the Bushite war on terror and has refused to roll back the unconstitutional executive usurpations that so outraged his supporters. And yet Democrats expect liberals to toe the line and shut the hell up lest the Republicans take advantage of their dissent. In fact, for the most part, the “professional left” of policy intellectuals, public interest advocates, and opinion journalists have done just that.
What’s fascinating about the Democrats is how consistently they have squandered enormous political advantages. The party’s leaders have apparently internalized Republican propaganda to the point that they feel they do not deserve to rule; consequently, when Democrats come to power, they always negotiate with themselves prior to meeting their opponents, make the tough-minded decision to betray their most loyal supporters, and profess shock and anger when the GOP—which never makes the mistake of publicly spurning its base—refuses to accept the purported bipartisan compromise. What results, of course, is that the Democratic Party, over and over again, enacts some version of the Republican agenda.
Glenn Beck's Sunday School Class
I watched Glenn Beck's show last night for the first time (not all the way through). It was certainly much different than what I expected (or what I had seen before). He sat in front of a small audience, and it felt like a Sunday School class, actually. If you can believe this, on either side of him were pictures, one of Gandhi and one of Dietrich Bonhoeffer. Yes, that's right, heroes of the liberal/left. And then behind him on the wall were the words 'Faith, Hope, and Charity'.
This man is changing so far, so fast....I don't think he is long for Fox News. Before long, he'll be doing sermons on the Lifetime cable channel.
This man is changing so far, so fast....I don't think he is long for Fox News. Before long, he'll be doing sermons on the Lifetime cable channel.
Monday, October 11, 2010
Age of Austerity
Robert Samuelson of the WaPo writes convincingly and realistically of the 'new age of austerity':
Also, somehow we've got to help those who are really struggling with the very basics of life--employment, a house, food, and basic health care--get by, because, again, if we don't, you could see a political radicalization that won't be good. This would seem to argue for more 'welfare state' initiatives, I know. Part of the answer, it seems to me, is pulling back from the huge expenses associated with our foreign military adventures, and getting health care costs under control. But neither of those things are going to be easy.
We have entered the Age of Austerity. It's already arrived in Europe and is destined for the United States. Governments throughout Europe are cutting social spending and raising taxes -- or contemplating doing so. The welfare state and the bond market have collided, and the welfare state is in retreat. Even rich countries find the costs too high, but the sudden austerity could perversely trigger a new financial crisis.I think this is correct, but to avoid political radicalization in the US, I think the rich who have benefited so magnificently durng the last 30 years, while the ordinary person has either just gotten along or has declined economically, need to do more than their 'fair share' of the tax increases. Hence, the sensibility of the Democratic proposal to return the tax rates of the wealthy back to the year 2000 (about a 4% increase). I think even more would be better, but wouldn't ever get through Congress.
Also, somehow we've got to help those who are really struggling with the very basics of life--employment, a house, food, and basic health care--get by, because, again, if we don't, you could see a political radicalization that won't be good. This would seem to argue for more 'welfare state' initiatives, I know. Part of the answer, it seems to me, is pulling back from the huge expenses associated with our foreign military adventures, and getting health care costs under control. But neither of those things are going to be easy.
Everybody Was Out to Lunch
An excerpt from the latest screed by James Howard Kunstler, a great American, writing about the new mortgage foreclosure scandel:
Did nobody, for instance at Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, review any of the paperwork fluttering in from places like Countrywide or Ditech and scores of other boiler rooms where mortgages were hatched like Peking ducklings? There was an awful lot of it, I'm sure, but aren't there a lot of seat-warmers at Fannie and Freddie who collect their salaries for the express purpose of reading mortgage documents? Was nobody the least bit suspicious about the mysterious flurry of "restaurant employees" and "lawn-care technicians" buying million-dollar condominiums with no money down at terms that would make a three-card monte dealer weep with laughter? After all, they had to sort and bundle all these contracts for the likes of Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan and Citibank - the list isn't that long, but you get the picture....
And speaking of these august institutions, didn't anybody in the divisions charged with assembling complex securities composed of mortgages, or composed of bets against bundles of mortgages, or composed of some notion of something dimly related to a rumor of mortgage lending - didn't any of these expensively-educated chaps or lasses pause a moment in their aardvark-like labors of bonus-seeking to withdraw their snouts from the moist ground where swindles pupate and at least goggle in self-admiration at the fantastic legal novelty of their endeavors.
And what of the numberless agencies, federal on down, starting with, say, the Office of Thrift Supervision, or the Comptroller of the Currency, or the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, or the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve, or the chairpersons of a dozen senate and house subcommittees on matters related to finance, or the various inspectors general from sea to shining sea or the attorneys general of all fifty states plus the US Department of Justice, or the countless fiduciary officers of the pension funds who tripped over each other buying all the tainted paper churned out like so much Purina Rat Chow - or, for Godsake, a lonely loan officer here or there with something resembling a conscience?
Nobody in the USA noticed anything the least bit fishy. And now all that epic rot has eaten through the last hanging tendrils of the banking system. And the whole shootin' match is fixing to seize up and blow like a Chevy Big Block Super Stroker 632 engine that some clown has poured karo syrup into.
Fiscal Conservative + Anti-War + Gay = Libertarian
In reflecting on his ten years as a blogger, Andrew Sullivans tells of his evolution as an 'anti-war conservative':
I'm beginning to find myself at that place as well.
Watching the national security state achieve more and more power and less and less accountability, observing the sheer horror of counter-insurgencies in places we could never understand or master, seeing how the absolute evil of torture could not just enter the heart of American government, but be defended by so many, enabled by the media's cowardice and entrenched by a refusal to prosecute it or even call it by its proper name ... well, these events have indeed radicalized me. I have become an instinctually anti-war conservative, rather than an instinctually pro-war one. I do not understand how anyone who has lived and breathed this last decade could not reach a similar conclusion.
Earlier, Andrew refers to himself as a 'Whiggish Tory'. But anyone who is both fiscally conservative, very skeptical of the ability of government to better human life, and anti-war is almost by definition more a 'libertarian' of the Murry Rothbard variety than anything else.
I'm beginning to find myself at that place as well.
Who is Glenn Beck?
Here are a few highlights from a NYT Magazine article on Glenn Beck, who is someone, I'll admit, I don't understand:
--He's not all that interested in the Tea Party movement.
--Beck doesn't speak with an ideological certainty, a la Hannity or O'Reilly."He showed little interest in the results from primary elections held the day before — upsets in Delaware and New York for Tea Party candidates whose followers often invoke Beck and Palin as spiritual leaders and even promote them as a prospective presidential ticket in 2012.
“Not involved with the Tea Party,” Beck told me, shrugging. While many identify Beck with a political insurgency — as Rush Limbaugh was identified with the Republican sweep of 1994 — to believe that the nation suffers from “a political problem” comically understates things, in his view."
"Beck rarely speaks with the squinty-eyed certainty or smugness of Rush Limbaugh or his fellow Fox News hosts Bill O’Reilly and Sean Hannity. He often changes his mind or nakedly contradicts himself." He's more approachable, personable, even feminine about Beck. "Fans approach Beck and give him hugs. Do people feel they can hug Limbaugh? There is something feminine about Beck — the soft features, the crying on the air, the reflexive vulnerability. It sets him apart from the standard, testosterone-addled rant artists of cable and talk radio. Women tune into Beck’s radio show more heavily than they do to other conservative commentators....Beck’s staff and loyalists love to compare Beck with Oprah Winfrey."--His willingness to admit his mistakes may be somewhat self-serving, rather than truly humble.
"Beck is constantly admitting his weaknesses and failures, which he wields as both a crutch and a shield. 'Maybe Glenn’s transparency is what keeps him out of trouble,' says Robert Beath, Beck’s drama teacher at Sehome High School in Bellingham, Wash. Beath, who was fond of Beck as a teenager, said Beck appears to now think that his revelations grant him license. 'When he says, ‘I am not perfect,’ he seems to escape accountability for his various points of view. Yet he expects others to be accountable for their point of view without seeming to allow them the ‘I am not perfect’ exception.”--Beck is exceptionally polarizing.
“He has a spiritual connection to us; you can hear his heart speaking,” Susan Trevethan, a psychiatric nurse from Milford, Conn., told me at the “Restoring Honor” rally. “I believe he has been divinely guided to be here in this place,” she said. “He is doing the research. He is teaching us.”
Or if you prefer: “Even the leather-winged shouting heads at Fox News look like intellectual giants next to this bleating, benighted Cassandra,” wrote The Buffalo Beast, in naming Beck one of the 50 most loathsome people in America in 2006. (No. 24 then, but in January he made it to No. 1.) “It’s like someone found a manic, doom-prophesying hobo in a sandwich board, shaved him, shot him full of Zoloft and gave him a show.”
Sunday, October 10, 2010
Impeaching Obama?
Michael Tomasky, writing in the New York Review of Books, thinks that the biggest result of a Republican takeover of Congress would be investigations:
In a morbid sort of way, it will be fascinating to see what will happen in a Congress populated by so many people keen to join it because they despise it. Whatever emerges, one thing is not in doubt: if the Republicans win the House, they will launch a series of investigations into the Obama administration, quite possibly leading to another impeachment drama.
This is not often discussed, but it is certainly no secret. Politico reported in late August:
Everything from the microscopic—the New Black Panther party—to the massive—think bailouts—is on the GOP to-do list, according to a half-dozen Republican aides interviewed by POLITICO.
Republican staffers say there won’t be any self-destructive witch hunts, but they clearly are relishing the prospect of extracting information from an administration that touts transparency.
And a handful of aggressive would-be committee chairmen—led by Reps. Darrell Issa (R-Calif.) and Lamar Smith (R-Texas)—are quietly gearing up for a possible season of subpoenas not seen since the Clinton wars of the late 1990s.6
Minnesota Representative Michelle Bachmann, who often speaks as the unrestrained id of this new right, said, when asked how Republicans should wield their subpoena power: “Oh, I think that’s all we should do. I think that all we should do is issue subpoenas and have one hearing after another.”
Republicans would deny that impeachment is ultimately on their minds. But why wouldn’t it be? They have shown repeatedly that they play to their base, and much of their base already believes that Obama is probably not an American citizen and therefore is an illegitimate president. In a Harris Poll from March, 24 percent of Republicans even agreed that Obama “may be the Antichrist.” When your most loyal voters think that, not trying to remove the man from office would amount to malpractice. If the Democrats are worried about the much-discussed “enthusiasm gap” between Republicans’ voters and theirs, perhaps bringing these issues out of the shadows would help close it.
"I Don't Feel LIke Anybody Cares About People Like Me"
In today's NYT is a story about Congressman Patrick Murphy, a moderate Democrat from north of Philadelphia, who won election in 2006 and was reelected in 2008, which included early support for Obama. This year, however, he's trailing in the polls to his Republican challenger. The journalist writer accompanied Murphy for three hours one evening as he went door to door in his district:
As Mr. Murphy moved from house to house, he tried to connect in any way he could, rattling off whatever biographical facts seemed to apply. He’d say he was in a “mixed marriage” — his wife is an enrolled Republican — or talk about his military background or his father, a retired Philadelphia police officer now working three part-time jobs. At a house with a pickup truck in the driveway plastered with Philadelphia Flyers bumper stickers, he remarked that he had played hockey as a child at a rink in neighboring Bristol Borough. To a woman wearing a crucifix, he said he had once been named altar boy of the year at his local parish.
Very few people seemed to want to actually listen to him. They jumped in with long lists of grievances: taxes, job losses, immigration, crooked local officials, junked cars in neighbors’ yards.
Marge Reed, 75, opened her screen door and before he could complete a sentence said, “You know what, Mr. Murphy, I don’t believe anything anybody tells me anymore.” She apologized for her frankness but said it was to be expected because of her Irish heritage. “I’m Irish, too,” Mr. Murphy said, as if she might not know that. “So is your opponent,” she said, and they both laughed. She told Mr. Murphy that she planned to vote for him, then continued giving him a piece of her mind.
Little of the anger Mr. Murphy encountered was aimed directly at him or even at President Obama. Mr. Murphy never once mentioned the president’s name, and, oddly, over the course of three hours, neither did any of the Levittown residents. People just did not like their situation or the general drift of the country, and seemed to hold everyone in a position of power — locally and in Washington — responsible.
I called Marge Reed the next day. She had worked for the Spiegel catalog company at a store in Levittown where people picked up their orders. She said she had lost much of her retirement nest egg in the stock market and was living on $13,750 a year and having a hard time paying for her prescriptions. Her husband died in 1993. “I don’t feel like anybody cares about people like me,” she said. “I remember President Obama talking about how he worried about his mother paying her health bills when she had cancer. Well, I’m somebody’s mother, too.”
Rick Rook, 59, a retired Air Force man, said he was not sure that he would vote at all. “I know why people go into politics,” he said. “They’re idealistic. But they get to Washington because somebody gave them money and then they’ve got to return the favor. I still believe in our system, but I don’t believe in the politicians.”
Mr. Murphy’s campaign has vehemently contested the accuracy of a late September poll that had him trailing Mr. Fitzpatrick by 14 points among likely voters, pointing out that the same pollster, G. Terry Madonna of Franklin and Marshall College, had him well behind in his 2006 race just weeks before the election. “I’m not saying the race is over,” Mr. Madonna said when I called him. “The poll was taken at five weeks out and there were a large number of undecideds. Murphy could still win. I don’t think, politically speaking, he’s a dead man walking.”
My walk with Mr. Murphy in Levittown began in a steady drizzle, which as the night wore on became a cold, driving rain. He had an umbrella but didn’t use it. I wondered at times why he, or anyone, would want to win office. The low regard for public officials that pollsters are finding could be viscerally felt.
Several people shook Mr. Murphy’s hand and commented on how cold it was. They couldn’t believe that he was outside on such a horrid night. But they let him stand at the door. No one invited him in for so much as a cup of hot tea.
Saturday, October 9, 2010
The Shriveling of the Middle Class
The Right and the Left in America today are talking past the real problem in the American economy, as described here by Paul Craig Roberts, former assistant secretary of the Treasury under Reagan:
The millions of unemployed today are blamed on the popped real estate bubble and the subprime derivative financial crisis. However, the US economy has been losing jobs for a decade. As manufacturing, information technology, software engineering, research, development, and tradable professional services have been moved offshore, the American middle class has shriveled. The ladders of upward mobility that made American an “opportunity society” have been dismantled.
The wage and salary cost savings obtained by giving Americans’ jobs to Chinese and Indians have enriched corporate CEOs, shareholders, and Wall Street at the expense of the middle class and America’s consumer economy.
The loss of middle class jobs and incomes was covered up for years by the expansion of consumer debt to substitute for the lack of income growth. Americans refinanced their homes and spent the equity, and they maxed out their credit cards.
Consumer debt expansion has run its course, and there is no possibility of continuing to drive the economy with additions to consumer debt.
Economists and policymakers continue to ignore the fact that all employment in tradable goods and services can be moved offshore (or filled by foreigners brought in on H-1b and L-1 visas). The only replacement jobs are in nontradable domestic services, that is, those jobs that require “hands-on” activity, such as ambulatory health services, barbers, cleaning services, waitresses and bartenders--jobs that describe the labor force of a third world country. Even many of these jobs are now filed with foreigners brought in on R-1 type visas from Russia, Ukraine, Thailand, Romania, and elsewhere.
The loss of American jobs and the compression of consumer income by low wages has removed consumer demand as the driving force of the economy. This is the reason expansionary monetary and fiscal policies are having no effect.
The latest jobs report issued today shows that America’s transformation into a third world economy continues. The economy lost 95,000 jobs in September, mainly due to cuts in local education and federal employment. Part of the loss of 159,000 government jobs was offset by 64,000 new private sector jobs.
Where are the new jobs? They are in nontradable lowly paid domestic services: 32,000 were in health care and social services, and 33,900 were in food services and drinking places.
There you have it. That is America’s “New Economy.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


