Friday, October 3, 2008
Legends of the Fall
According to an article in today's NYT, the investment banking industry's risky behavior began in earnest about 4 years ago, when the government's Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) voted to allow the banks to greatly expand their debt levels (called 'leverage') in very risky investments, and then never properly monitored the allowed behavior. The author asserts that the leadership of the SEC, with their 'markets self-regulate' mentality, were never interested in the kind of oversight that might have prevented the meltdown of Bear, Stearns, Lehman, etc.
"The commission’s decision effectively to outsource its oversight to the firms themselves fit squarely in the broader Washington culture of the last eight years under President Bush. A similar closeness to industry and laissez-faire philosophy has driven a push for deregulation throughout the government, from the Consumer Product Safety Commission and the Environmental Protection Agency to worker safety and transportation agencies."
“'It’s a fair criticism of the Bush administration that regulators have relied on many voluntary regulatory programs,' said Roderick M. Hills, a Republican who was chairman of the S.E.C. under President Gerald R. Ford. 'The problem with such voluntary programs is that, as we’ve seen throughout history, they often don’t work.' As was the case with other agencies, the commission’s decision was motivated by industry complaints of excessive regulation at a time of growing competition from overseas."
“'We foolishly believed that the firms had a strong culture of self-preservation and responsibility and would have the discipline not to be excessively borrowing,' said Professor James D. Cox, an expert on securities law and accounting at Duke School of Law (and no relationship to Christopher Cox). 'Letting the firms police themselves made sense to me because I didn’t think the S.E.C. had the staff and wherewithal to impose its own standards and I foolishly thought the market would impose its own self-discipline. We’ve all learned a terrible lesson,' he added."
"Mr. Cox dismantled a risk management office created by Mr. Donaldson that was assigned to watch for future problems. While other financial regulatory agencies criticized a blueprint by Mr. Paulson, the Treasury secretary, that proposed to reduce their stature — and that of the S.E.C. — Mr. Cox did not challenge the plan, leaving it to three former Democratic and Republican commission chairmen to complain that the blueprint would neuter the agency. In the process, Mr. Cox has surrounded himself with conservative lawyers, economists and accountants who, before the market turmoil of recent months, had embraced a far more limited vision for the commission than many of his predecessors."
Lesson: Banks and businesses will sometimes tend to push the boundaries and take risks far beyond reasonable limits in order to make money. They are not completely self-regulating. If they are big enough so that it is seriously detrimental to society for them to fail, then oversight regulation by government must be serious and effective. But for this to work, the governing regulators must believe in regulation. Appropriate government regulation is good, not bad, and it is essential to the proper functioning of market capitalism.
Thursday, October 2, 2008
Biden Won
Over all, I agree with David Gergen on CNN that Biden won the debate, which, given my political preferences, makes it a very good night.
Debate Favors Palin
I still agree with Andrew Sullivan: "Since she was selected, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has held more press conferences with American reporters than she has. Forget all this debate spin or pre-spin. Just give her a microphone, a roomful of inquisitive reporters and be done with it."
Heck of a Mess
The thing that scares me about Obama/Biden is not that they are too radical, but that they are both too Establishment in their thinking. On the one hand, this is somewhat reassuring that adults will be back in charge. But I think the problems facing us as a nation and the world are going to require a lot of outside-of-the-box thinking that I'm not sure that I see in the Democratic ticket.
We are closer than most people think to losing our superpower status in the world. The world is so disgusted with our national behavior and performance--politically, economically, and militarily--they may just turn against us, and we could then fall a lot harder and farther than most people alive today can comprehend. As Paul Krugman keeps saying, unless we turn things around, we're on the road to becoming 'a banana republic with nukes.'
Furthermore, we are close to hitting the wall of an ecological crisis, that will require the greatest cooperation the world has ever known if we are to escape in one piece. We've most likely peaked in world oil production, which will cause all kinds of problems. Right behind that is the still looming issue of world conflict, nuclear war and WMD terrorism.
We cannot return to business as usual of the last century, if we are going to survive as a civilization in any recognizable sense.
So I will vote for Obama/Biden, because they are obviously the better choice (which I'm going to elaborate on in a future series of posts). But I sure hope that they are ready to do the creative, and even 'radical' (as in, 'going to the root'), thinking that the next era is going to be forcing upon us. Because we are in a heck of a mess.
Frightened to Death
"But Thomas, a one-time supporter of President Bush, said McCain running mate Sarah Palin's recent interviews sealed his decision to vote for Democrat Barack Obama. 'She's not prepared at all,' Thomas, 70, said as he loaded groceries into his car outside a Sam's Club warehouse store on the outskirts of Huntsville. He said listening to Palin argue that Alaska's proximity to Russia was a foreign policy credential 'frightened me to death.' 'I went out on the golf course Thursday and that was what everyone was talking about,' Thomas said. 'They're very frightened about McCain and his age ... and to have Palin a heartbeat away.'"
Can Sarah Palin recover these skeptical votes (even from the South) with a good debate performance tonight? Possibly. I think it might depend upon whether they buy the fact that she really knows what she's talking about and can convincingly articulate it. I think her 'aw shucks' Joe Six-Pack facade isn't going to work anymore. Most people really don't want their next-door neighbor 'a heartbeat away' from the Oval Office.
But even if she performs well tonight, with memorized talking points and her vivacious beauty, isn't the reality of her unpreparedness already out there, as a scary reality that won't go away? As someone wrote, how do you prepare for the Bar exam without going to law school? Perhaps a genius who has been studying law on their own for years might be able to do it (Think Abraham Lincoln here, or perhaps another small-state governor, Bill Clinton, or a state-senator and short-time U.S. Senator, Barack Obama).
But Palin is clearly no genius; she can barely put words together into a coherent sentence about serious issues, if you've watched the CBS interviews. She is so clearly 'out of her league' as one conservative columnist put it, that honest conservatives who haven't been completely warped by partisan politics or Rush Limbaugh are bailing out on supporting her.
It seems to me that the only politicians who should be brought up from the 'minor leagues' to the 'majors' in one fell swoop are superstars (like Clinton and Reagan--and Obama, if you honestly think that coming out of the U.S. Senate, with the strong support of dozens of your Senate peers, is coming from the minor leagues).
Palin is obviously no superstar, except in the most superficial way, if you know what I mean.
Disgusted by Plutocrats
A starting point would be to remove tax subsidies on executive pay and allow courts to restructure mortgages as they do other kinds of debt. The Institute for Policy Studies in Washington estimates that U.S. taxpayers every year provide more than $20 billion in tax subsidies for executive pay.Among the strongest critics of inflated executive pay have been Warren Buffett and the late management guru, Peter Drucker, who argued that C.E.O. salaries should peak at no more than 20 or 25 times those of the average worker. (Last year, C.E.O.’s got an average of 344 times the wages of the typical worker.)
The truth is that with the complicity of boards of directors, C.E.O.’s hijack shareholder wealth in ways that are unconscionable. As The Wall Street Journal reported in June, if Eugene Isenberg, the 78-year-old C.E.O. of Nabors Industries, were to drop dead one of these days, his estate would be entitled to a “severance payment” of at least $263 million — more than the firm’s first-quarter net earnings.
With such greed oozing out of the corporate suite, and with financial companies enjoying the confidence of only 10 percent of Americans today (down from 36 percent in 2000), it’s no wonder that voters are repulsed by the idea of helping banks. Wall Street urgently needs to undertake its own housecleaning, for the public revulsion toward it undermines its own long-term interests.
For Young People Only
Wednesday, October 1, 2008
"Waist Deep In Evasions"
"Government should budget the way households supposedly do, conforming outlays to income. But the crisis came partly because so many households decided that it would be jolly fun to budget the way government does, hitching outlays to appetites."
"Beneath Americans' perfunctory disapproval of government deficits lurks an inconvenient truth: They enjoy deficits, by which they are charged less than a dollar for a dollar's worth of government. Conservatives participate in this, even though deficits fuel government's growth by obscuring its cost."
The Traitor
"Allow me to introduce myself. I am a traitor and an idiot. Also, my mother should have aborted me and left me in a dumpster, but since she didn't, I should "off" myself."
"Those are a few nuggets randomly selected from thousands of e-mails written in response to my column suggesting that Sarah Palin is out of her league and should step down."
"The fierce reaction to my column has been both bracing and enlightening. After 20 years of column writing, I'm familiar with angry mail. But the past few days have produced responses of a different order. Not just angry, but vicious and threatening."
And, finally, her bottom line, with which I agree completely:
"Such extreme partisanship has a crippling effect on government, which may be desirable at times, but not now. More important in the long term is the less tangible effect of stifling free speech. My mail paints an ugly picture and a bleak future if we do not soon correct ourselves."
"Our day of reckoning may indeed be upon us. Between war and economic collapse, we have enormous challenges. It will take the best of everyone to solve them. That process begins minimally with a commitment to engage in civil discourse and a cease-fire in the war against unwelcome ideas. "
What Bill Maher Is Trying To Do
I'm trying to think of another nation where this is so clearly the case. The only ones that come to mind are: Israel, India, and Iran. (I could be totally wrong about this!) Israeli politics is riven by arguments over the place of Judaism in the Zionist vision. India, because I have the sense that many Indians are only nominally Hindu. And Iran, because it has a large population of fairly secularized young people, who while nominally Muslim, really like the ways of the European West, even while it is ruled by a strict Islamic clergy.
Maher's other comments were funny but don't cause me to lose my faith. He does a good job of pointing out some of the absurdities of religious belief and behavior, which actually is not very hard to do. (I occasionally do that on Sunday myself, for example, here.) But in doing so, he seems to think that he is demolishing the case for faith in God, when he really isn't. In fact, I thought it interesting that in an interview on Fresh Air on NPR, Maher had to admit the many wonderful teachings of Jesus in the New Testament. He came across sounding like a sarcastic Thomas Jefferson using his scissors to cut out all of the parts of the New Testament that were 'supernatural', leaving only the pure ethical teachings (hence the term 'Jefferson Bible')
Maher isn't the first and he won't be the last to do this (in addition to Jefferson, think Mark Twain, Clarence Darrow, Robert Ingersoll, etc.). These playful, sarcastic, and sometimes ferocious critics of religion actually play an important role in helping Christianity and the other world religions to be a little more self-critical and humble, as well as to reform themselves from within. And believe me, as human institutions, they (we) are far from perfect.
So let's not get all upset about Bill Maher and this movie. We all need a laugh now and again. And we do need to be reminded once in a while to be a little more humble. "Blessed are the poor in spirit [humble], for theirs is the kingdom of heaven." (Matthew 5:3)