Friday, October 28, 2011

Mormonism's Biggest Problem Is Joseph Smith

There is something disturbing about Mormonism.  And it has nothing to do with whether or not it is Christian.
(My personal answer to that issue is: No, Mormonism should not be considered as a Christian denomination.  It is just too far outside the circle of what makes Christianity Christian, viz. the Bible and basic biblical Trinitarian theology.  Rather, LDS (The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints) is, as Indiana University historian Jan Shipps put it in her 1987 book Mormonism: The Story of a New Religious Tradition, a brand new religion in history that precipitated out of 19th Century American Protestanism.)

Mormonism has a destructive virus embedded in its code that should logically end up destroying it.   And that is that the central focus of its faith, the hinge on which it swings, is not Jesus Christ but Joseph Smith.  To put it another way, the credibility of Mormonism rises and falls almost solely on the credibility of Joseph Smith and his revelations as found in The Book of Mormon, the Doctrine and Covenants, and the Pearl of Great Price.  Take away Joseph Smith, and Mormonism loses its very soul, its raison d'être.

Houston, we have a problem.

And here it is: unlike the founders of any of the great world religions including Christianity, we know a great deal about Joseph Smith, because he lived in 19th century upstate New York (not 1st century CE Palestine or 6th century BCE India).  There were newspapers, magazines, libraries, courts, diaries and journals, and all kinds of written sources all around him there, and many of them have been preserved.  We know a great deal about Smith, his father and mother, his wife Emma, his extended relatives, his neighbors, his community, and his eventual Mormon followers.

So, whereas the Mormon Church has created over the last 180 years a mythologized, idealized, "faith-promoting" picture of its "prophet, seer and revelator" Joseph Smith, we now have an alternative, historically-grounded, factually accurate account of his life.  And the two don't match.  At all.

Disinterested scholars of Mormonism and Joseph Smith--many of them ex-Mormons in fact, like biographer Fawn Brodie and historian D. Michael Quinn--have discovered that this young man was not really a saint or mystic or prophet at all.  Indeed, far from it.

Frankly, I did not necessarily expect this when I started reading in the literature.  As a rule, I tend to give the founders of religion--prophets, saints, mystics, etc--the benefit of the doubt, believing that at the core of their mission was a good heart and an intense desire to get close to God--however they conceived God--and to do God's will, as they understood it.

This isn't what I have found with Joseph Smith.  In fact, it looks to me, to put it bluntly, that he was either an imposter or a deluded zealot from the very beginning of his role in the founding of Mormonism. 

For example, years before he 'translated' the Book of Mormon or organized his new church, between the ages of 18 and 25, it is now clear that he was heavily involved in the 'folk magic' that was rampant in that area at that time.  (This is the essence of Quinn's book Early Mormonism and the Magic Worldview, for which scholarship he was excommunicated by the LDS in 1993.)  It appears that Smith used these magical 'tools'--divining rods, incantations, magic circles, talismans, crystal gazing and 'seer stones', and the like--all as a means of treasure-hunting, ie. as a way of duping those around him into giving him money.  In fact, he was actually arrested and convicted for this activity during this time, historical evidence of which has been found in the last decade or two, much to the  extreme consternation of the Mormon Church. 

It was also during this same time that he allegedly found the famous golden plates (using his magic) and 'translated' them (using, again, his magic--a crystal ball-type stone in a top hat into which he put his face) into what became his Book of Mormon, the new scripture of the people called Mormon.  And in 1830, in Palmyra, New York, this magic-saturated and obviously talented young man of 25 called his congregation together, believers in him and his new magic book. 

It took only one year for the Palmyra, NY community to run him (and those who would continue to follow him) out of town.  He moved to Ohio.  The same thing happened there, and he moved to Missouri.  The same thing happened there, and he moved to Illinois.  And the same thing happened there, but before he could move again, a mob murdered him in the local jail where he was being held.  (After which, Brigham Young took charge and moved the flock out of the US and into Utah, then a part of Mexico.) This all happened because the things Joseph Smith and his followers were saying and doing were simply outrageous and offensive to the ordinary Christian people of those American communities.

Most disgusting of all is the now-verified serial adultery of Joseph Smith with teenage girls and the wives of his followers (33 of them, at least).  Blasphemously, he tried to justify his obscene behavior by claiming it to be God's command to him (though in his lifetime, he denied that publicly).  This so-called 'polygamy' or 'plural marriage'--aka fornicating with every woman he could manage to persuade with his gift of 'God-talk'--spread to the other Mormon leaders and soon became the basis for an entire Mormon way of life, which lasted into the 20th century.  (His successor as President of the Mormon Church, Brigham Young, had no less than 55 'wives', which, in its own way, is very impressive!)

Mormonism, because of its polygamous lifestyle, is the only religion that the US federal government, famous for its 'freedom of religion', has ever threatened to squash.  And that is the only reason that Mormonism outlawed its polygamy, officially in 1890 and in reality several decades later.

Unfortunately, history tells us quite clearly that it is very unlikely that Joseph Smith was who he said he was: the greatest of all prophets and the restorer of true Christianity.  No, he seems to have been the complete opposite.

I feel sorry for Mormons, I really do.  They are, on the whole, really nice, very good people.  Of that, there is little doubt.  It's just too bad they had such a screwed-up founder.


  1. hey, Carl. Two interesting reads are One Nation Under Gods, and Secret Ceremonies, the later by a mormon journalist named Lakke, who was excommunicated for it.

  2. Your posts on Mormonism are very interesting. I learn a bit more each time you post on the subject. I have several friends who belong (or once belonged) to out-of-the-mainstream faiths (ie: Mormon, Amish, Menonite). What I know about religion is minimal because I decided to become Agnostic when I was 17 yrs old for some very personal reasons. But the little bit I know about Mormonism leaves me believing it is a bit cultish, a bit religious, and a bit misogynistic. But then so is the Catholic faith even though it is considered mainstream. There is the "Church of Jesus Chist of Latter Day Saints" designation that would lead me to believe it is a Christian denomination. The conservative right seems to think it is a problem for Romney but then everyone thought that being a Catholic was a problem for JFK! The big thing that appears to have everyone bothered is the "sister wives" thing. You are right, Mormons are really good people with strange ideas and beliefs. If we Americans could just be more tolerant this wouldn't be a problem for us or them. I believe every religion is singed around the edges a bit if you really study them. Just my view...

  3. Although there are many Bible scriptures that point the way to a religious upheaval and restoration of the Ancient Church established by Jehovah of the
    Old Testament and Jesus Christ of the New Testament you are correct. If Joseph Smith was a psychotic young man with an extremely vivid imagination who never made 1 anachronism when (writing?) the Book of Mormon was not who he claimed to be then the LDS people are completely off base.But if they do believe in Jesus Christ as the divine Son of God as their savior then I suspect they will be saved like every other born again christian. People throughout history have always had trouble with a living Prophet. For some strange reason it seems to be easier to believe in the dead ones. The children of Israel didn't want to follow Moses. The people at the time of Noah, well, we know what happened to them, don't we? If God is all that every religion makes him out to be then I for one would like to believe that he is alive and well in heaven. Just a footnote here.I have read many books of the apocrypha and so much of that information coincides with the LDS beliefs. Not to mention the temples and temple ordinances. If anyone were curious the Masons have had the temple ceremonies for a few thousand years now. So I am not here to criticize anyone for believing what they want, I am curious as to why if you are such good Christians in your own right why not let the Mormons alone. What are you afraid of? I know alot of them and
    they really are good people for the most part. Sorry to Rant.

  4. I know this comment is a few years later. The problem with leaving "them" alone means that no one cares if they go to hell. Although they believe in Jesus Christ and their God, they do not believe in the same that we as Christians do.. and for them to idolize a false God and follow a false prophet they are condemning themselves to hell. It is our job as Christians to spread the word of God and to get the truth to people who are misled. It's not about judging anyone it's about showing them God's grace.

  5. I know this comment is a few years later. The problem with leaving "them" alone means that no one cares if they go to hell. Although they believe in Jesus Christ and their God, they do not believe in the same that we as Christians do.. and for them to idolize a false God and follow a false prophet they are condemning themselves to hell. It is our job as Christians to spread the word of God and to get the truth to people who are misled. It's not about judging anyone it's about showing them God's grace.